We use only the finest ingredients.  Every pie made to order.
Come taste award our winning pizza and wings.

Average Joe's Pizza is located inside Average Joe's Beeernasiun on Downer street. We serve up award winning pizza and wings. We are home to the original Grilled Wings. Every dish is created using only the freshest, finest ingredients. We never use frozen ingredients. There is no microwave oven at Average Joe's Pizza. We hand toss every pizza and use only fresh toppings. Average Joe's  is proud of its long tradition of serving Baldwinsville pizza lovers.

We are the home of the first grilled wings in Baldwinsville and Central New York.

Thanks to everyone that came out and voted us the BEST PIZZA and BEST WINGS at the Taste of Baldwinsville 2009 & 2011.

Check Out Our Menu & Our Daily Specials

"Best Pizza" award from
Taste of Baldwinsville
2010, 2011, 2012 & 2013!

Full menu also available next door!

Open 7 Days A Week

Monday thru Thursday 3pm to 10pm
Friday 3pm to 11pm
Saturday 12pm to 11pm
Sunday 12pm to 9pm

---

Gift Certificates Available
We Cater All Big Parties & Events